CP23/24: Capital deduction for redress: personal investment firms

Consultation opens
29/11/2023
29/11/2023
Consultation closes
20/03/2024

We are consulting on proposals to require personal investment firms (PIFs) to be more prudent and set aside capital for potential redress liabilities at an early stage. This consultation also includes a Discussion Chapter to look at broader improvements to the prudential regime for PIFs. 

We have published a Dear CEO letter alongside this consultation, reminding firms they must not seek to avoid potential redress liabilities.  

Read CP23/24 (PDF)

See our infographic

Read our Dear CEO letter (PDF)

Why we are consulting

We are concerned that some PIFs (personal investment firms) are causing consumers harm. We are seeing significant redress liabilities falling to the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS). We therefore want to strengthen our prudential requirements so that PIFs have to hold more capital for redress. 

Our proposals would require PIFs: 

  • to quantify an amount for their potential redress liabilities  
  • to set aside capital resources for potential redress liabilities through a new capital deduction, and  
  • where they are not holding enough capital to meet potential redress liabilities, to comply with an asset retention requirement  

Who this is for

  • Personal investment firms, including new market entrants. See the CP for an explanation of what PIFs are.

It will also be of interest to: 

  • consumers who receive pensions or investments advice   
  • professional and trade bodies representing PIFs   
  • consumer organisations  
  • providers of professional indemnity insurance (PII) to PIFs  
  • providers of investment platform, professional and other services to PIFs 
  • compliance consultancies, auditors and other professional services that support PIFs  
  • all firms that pay into the Life Distribution and Investment Intermediation (LDII) funding class of the FSCS

Next steps

Online response form

Given the importance of getting this right, we will hold an extended consultation period of 16 weeks. We will also run a pilot data collection for a sample of firms during the consultation period. We will consider the results of this alongside consultation responses before making final rules. We aim to publish a Policy Statement, including our response to feedback, in H2 2024. We expect rules to come into force in H1 2025. 

Please send us your comments by 20 March 2024.

Background

We want to ensure that the firms that generate redress costs are better able to meet them without recourse to the FSCS and that should a firm fail there is more capital for FSCS recoveries. In short, we want the polluter to pay. This is in line with our commitments in the 2021 Consumer Investments Strategy and in response to feedback to our 2020 Consumer Investments Call for Input and our 2022 Compensation Framework Review Discussion Paper.