We found the proportion of credit card customers in persistent debt decreased between 2018 and 2023. Our evaluation shows what worked, what didn't and what lenders can learn.
Read Evaluation Paper 26/1 (PDF)[2]
Persistent debt is when a customer pays more in interest and fees than they repay of what they borrowed, over a period of 18 months or more.
In 2018, we introduced rules[3] requiring credit card firms to:
- Identify customers in persistent debt.
- Take escalating steps to help those customers increase repayments where affordable and repay their balance more quickly.
We judge our rules helped. But events such as the Covid-19 pandemic and the cost-of-living crisis also affected consumer outcomes, so we cannot say our rules caused these changes.
What we found
Our evaluation covered 2018 to March 2023:
- 7% of credit card accounts were in persistent debt in 2018. By early 2023, this was 3%.
- Customers in persistent debt paid less in interest and fees each month, and fewer paid fees.
- Most customers who received a letter notifying them of being in persistent debt left within 18 months.
- Firms' total costs of complying were £281.6m. This was slightly below the range of £294.6m to £334.1m that we estimated in our policy statement (PS18/4).
- The rules work less well for customers who can't afford to pay more. These customers may need wider support with financial difficulty.
Our findings are indicative rather than precise. Some firms' data had gaps and inconsistencies that were disproportionate to resolve.
Key lessons for credit card lenders
Focus on customer engagement
Not all customers opened their persistent debt communications, and some kept making minimum repayments over long periods.
Firms could make greater use of social strategies to encourage behaviour change.
Examples could include:
- Using social norms, such as ‘x% of people make their payments on time’.
- Personal stories to convey information about persistent debt.
- Encouraging customers earlier in the persistent debt journey to call them and commit to higher monthly repayments.
Share good practice
Firms took different approaches to supporting customers, and this led to different outcomes.
Trade associations could run forums to share what works.
Key lessons for our future evaluations
We faced challenges collecting and processing data, and complying with this request was difficult for some firms.
We will consider collecting data more regularly and prioritise using regulatory returns, where possible.
We will decide when it’s proportionate to use analytical methods that show cause and effect.
Next steps
For firms and other interested parties:
Send us your views on the Evaluation Paper to [email protected].
- Lenders should check their approach to persistent debt against the lessons above and contact us[4] with any questions.
For the FCA:
- We will consider your feedback and use it to improve our future evaluations.
Background
In July 2016, we published the final findings of our credit card market study[5]. We found competition was working well for most consumers. But more than 5 million consumers were potentially in problematic debt, and lenders had little reason to help them.
We published our final rules in PS18/4[3], after consulting in CP17/10 and CP17/43.
The rules require firms to intervene at 18, 27 and 36 months, with progressively stronger action for customers who remain in persistent debt.
These rules came into force on 1 March 2018, and firms had to comply fully by 1 September 2018.
Our Rule Review Framework (2023)[6] says we should check whether our rules work. Doing so helps us protect consumers from harm and learn what works for people in financial difficulty.